How to Make a Holiday Simmer Pot That Smells Like a Hallmark Movie

Picture this: You’re in a cozy little cabin, snowflakes are drifting down outside your window, and there’s a pot simmering on the stove that smells like cinnamon-spiced dreams and small-town romance. That, my friend, is the power of a holiday simmer pot. It’s basically aromatherapy dressed in flannel pajamas, and YES - it can make your home smell like a Hallmark movie!

Please note: This article contains affiliate links, and that means that I may earn a commission if you buy something. Read my full disclosure here.

I started making these little pots of joy years ago when I was living in Colorado. Something about that crisp mountain air made me crave all the cozy. One snowy December afternoon, I tossed some orange slices and cinnamon sticks into a pot on the stove, added a splash of vanilla, and BAM - hooked for life. It smelled like Christmas morning and a cookie bakery had a baby. Total game changer.

What Is a Simmer Pot, Anyway?

Think of a simmer pot as the OG essential oil diffuser. It's a mix of natural ingredients - fruits, herbs, spices - that simmer gently in water on your stovetop (or slow cooker) to scent your entire home. No synthetic candles, no overpowering sprays - just pure, plant-powered cozy vibes.

Plus, it's totally customizable and makes your house smell CLEAN, fresh, and holiday-ready without any of that fake fragrance funk. Clean lifestyle goals, achieved.

Hallmark Movie-Inspired Simmer Pot Ingredients

Here’s the cast of characters for your very own holiday-scent blockbuster:

1 orange, sliced (hello citrusy brightness!)
3–4 cinnamon sticks (warm + spicy = YES please)
1 tablespoon whole cloves (adds depth and a lil’ nostalgia)
1 star anise (for that “fancy apothecary” energy)
A handful of cranberries (they pop with color AND scent)
2 sprigs fresh rosemary or pine (gives that forest-fresh finish)
1 teaspoon vanilla extract (like a cookie in scent form)
3–4 drops essential oils - I love:
- Sweet Orange
- Cinnamon Bark
- Clove
- Fir Needle or Pine

Optional: a splash of apple cider, a few juniper berries, or dried lemon slices for extra flair!

How to Make Your Holiday Simmer Pot

Fill a medium saucepan about ¾ full with water.
Add all your ingredients.
Bring to a gentle boil, then reduce to a low simmer.
Let it do its aromatic thing - just make sure to top off with water as needed.

Hot tip: Want all-day fragrance without babysitting the stove? Throw everything in a small slow cooker and set to low with the lid off. BOOM - holiday heaven on loop.

Why It’s Better Than Candles

Look, I love a good candle - but not all candles are created equal. Most store-bought ones are loaded with synthetic fragrances that can mess with your vibe (and your air quality). Simmer pots, on the other hand?

100% NATURAL
Non-toxic and pet-friendly
Customizable to your mood or season
Part aromatherapy, part potpourri, part homemaking magic

You’re basically becoming your own holiday-scent sommelier.

Simmer Pot Gift Bags - The Cutest, Coziest DIY Present

These are SO easy to whip up and they make the sweetest handmade gift. Here's how:

What you need:

Small kraft paper or cellophane bags
Dried orange slices, cinnamon sticks, cloves, cranberries, a mini sprig of pine or rosemary
Optional: a small glass vial with essential oils or a sachet of spice blend
Twine or ribbon
A tag with simmering instructions (handwritten or printed - bonus points for glitter pens)

Wrap it all up, tie it with a bow, and you’ve got a thoughtful little gift that’s under $5 and smells like you totally have your life together. ✨

Perfect for:

Neighbors
Teachers
Hostess gifts
Secret Santa
Literally anyone who loves their home smelling like joy

Make It Your Holiday Tradition

Simmer pots aren’t just about the smell - they’re about the FEELING. They slow you down. They fill your space with comfort. They give you that fuzzy, nostalgic, cookie-scented pause in the middle of the season's chaos.

Light some fairy lights, pop on your favorite holiday playlist, and let this become part of your annual ritual. Your future December self will thank you.

So go ahead - channel your inner Hallmark heroine, slice up those oranges, and simmer your way to seasonal bliss. And if you make a gift bag, tag me - I want to see your adorable creations!!

Here are some more great posts you might like to check out: